8 or 12 team playoff?

[GBP4EVER]

Sure as hell it’s not half. And that’s assuming they get 4 in top 12 each year which is not a lock. Problem with other P5 conferences they are too heavy, 1-2 teams maybe 3. Not deep

Still SEC is deep every year go at worst you see likely 3 teams in every year with them. I just dont' want to see one conference over repersented

 

[TW]

Not necessarily. Last years top 12. 4 SEC , 2 B1G, 2 Big 12, 2 ACC, 2 G5

1	Alabama	11-0
2	Clemson	10-1
3	Ohio State	6-0
4	Notre Dame	10-1
5	Texas A&M	8-1
6	Oklahoma	8-2
7	Florida	8-3
8	Cincinnati	9-0
9	Georgia	7-2
10	Iowa State	8-3
11	Indiana	6-1
12	Coastal Carolina	11-0
13		And

This does point out the situation. But, strangely enough, 4 in from the SEC with 12 teams is 1/3 of the entries. 2 in with 4 entries is 1/2 the entries. Oddly enough, a lower percentage with the 12 team format, but the optics really suck!

 

[FlaPack]

Still SEC is deep every year go at worst you see likely 3 teams in every year with them. I just dont' want to see one conference over repersented

Then the other conferences need to get better. It’s really that simple

 

[GBP4EVER]

Then the other conferences need to get better. It’s really that simple

Still SEC they have and always will be able recurit better kids then others.

 

[FlaPack]

Still SEC they have and always will be able recurit better kids then others.

So just give the other schools a pass because they can’t compete? Ok Penn State your 9-2 and ranked 11 so let’s give you a spot over 9th ranked Florida just to be fair? Please

 

[GBP4EVER]

So just give the other schools a pass because they can’t compete? Ok Penn State your 9-2 and ranked 11 so let’s give you a spot over 9th ranked Florida just to be fair? Please

Is it fair now? Right now it can be politics and BS how teams are picked to the playoffs.

 

[FlaPack]

This does point out the situation. But, strangely enough, 4 in from the SEC with 12 teams is 1/3 of the entries. 2 in with 4 entries is 1/2 the entries. Oddly enough, a lower percentage with the 12 team format, but the optics really suck!

And 2 from G5. The debate is always going to be what does the committee use for criteria and honestly they seem to move the goal posts a little each year. But then my message to the rest of the P5 especially the Pac 12, step it up

 

[FlaPack]

Is it fair now? Right now it can be politics and BS how teams are picked to the playoffs.

No it’s not politics, the best 4 teams have got selected each year. Sure there has been some debate but little outrage. So yeah based on the system it’s fair.

 

[FlaPack]

 

[GBP4EVER]

No it’s not politics, the best 4 teams have got selected each year. Sure there has been some debate but little outrage. So yeah based on the system it’s fair.

Though that one year was it not questionable about OSU getting in?